Book Reviews Epic Fantasy Fantasy

Perilous Seas by Dave Duncan




The third book in Dave Duncan’s A Man of his Word series continues to build on the momentum of the prior two books in the series, but it moves with new energy and a faster pace than those previous novels. Our two main characters are still progressing with their own stories, but it seems as if they’re—finally!—each navigating a course which will draw them back together and therefore bring the story to its final climax. ‘Seems’ is probably the key word here. With a fourth book still coming after this one, I knew going in that the story was not yet coming to an end. Nevertheless, we see the most character growth to date for both Rap and Inos, though as usual it seems Rap’s story contains greater depth and progresses further that that of Inos.

Though I noticed some of the same confusing prose and skipping about that caused me some consternation in the previous books, I won’t harp on that anymore here. I will say that the writing is about the same, and not as superb as I have generally found with Duncan’s later novels. Even here, though, Duncan has a knack for subtle horror, I’ll call it, where the reader is seemingly transported to a wondrous land reminiscent of a fairy tale, where even if something bad does happen it won’t have permanent ramifications. But with Duncan this is often only a façade; the world is harmless enough, right up until a jotunn raiding party slaughters, rapes, and burns to the ground an entire village. It’s a subtle technique which I’ve seen Duncan use in many of his novels and it’s always a bit of a slap in the face and a reminder that the stakes are real.

Thinking back, Perilous Seas is slightly better than the first two books in the series, but it still doesn’t rise to the level I was hoping given the good things I’ve heard about this series. Granted, the books are going on thirty years old now, so I’m willing to cut them some slack and look at it through the lens of a series written in the 1990’s (that’s why I’ve given each of the books, including this one, three rockets and not anything lower). A Man of His Word is entertaining, but it continues to move too slowly with too little character development. While the pace does pick up relative to the other novels, it’s taken a lot of page turning to get here and I fear a lot more before I’ll reach the end of book four. Still, I can see the many threads of the story just beginning to come together, and so I’m moving on to the final book in the series with high hopes that Duncan brings it all together in a satisfying way.

Hey there! In addition to writing reviews of other people's books, I'm also an author myself. If you liked this review or would like to read my work, please consider joining me over on Ko-fi. Thank you in advance for your support!

You may also like

The Alchemist's Pursuit
by Dave Duncan

The third installment in Dave Duncan's Venetian fantasy/mystery series finds Nostradamus and his app...

The Alchemist's Apprentice
by Dave Duncan

Nostradamus has predicted a government official's murder and now that person has wound up dead. Did ...

Lord of the Fire Lands
by Dave Duncan

Lord of the Fire Lands by Dave Duncan continues the story begun in The Gilded Chain and ends with a ...

Leave a Comment